Dr. Laura's Newsletter

Monthly tips to thrive in your work and life.

Research-backed insights on leadership, resilience, and well-being — straight to your inbox.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Dr. Laura
Dr. Laura
  • SPEAKING
  • COACHING
  • ABOUT
  • BOOKS
  • COMMUNITY
CONTACT
Back to Blog

When "Stay Positive" Becomes a Problem: Unpacking Toxic Positivity at Work

November 19, 2026

A women sitting in an office at work with a forced grin hiding sadness in her eyes while holding a mask with a happy smile in her hand.

Toxic positivity isn't about being optimistic; it's about feeling pressured to stay positive even when things aren't okay. Explore how this workplace pattern affects employees, why it matters, and how it can prevent people from speaking up about real concerns. Learn how to embrace realistic optimism and create a workplace where people feel heard, supported, and safe to be honest.

What Is Toxic Positivity, Really?

I talk a lot about toxic leadership, but there's a quieter, sneakier pattern showing up in workplaces that deserves just as much attention: toxic positivity.

Toxic positivity is the pressure to stay upbeat no matter what, even when you're stressed, grieving, burnt out, or dealing with something genuinely unfair. It shows up in phrases like "just stay positive," "good vibes only," or "it could be worse."

Let me be clear: positivity itself isn't the problem. I'm a big believer in gratitude and optimism, and I practice both daily. Positivity becomes toxic when it's used to dismiss, minimize, or shut down what someone is actually feeling. When your real emotions get waved away with a cheerful platitude, you don't feel better, you feel unseen.

Toxic Positivity vs. Toxic Leadership: Not the Same Thing

I spend most of my time researching toxic leadership, those overt or covert behaviours that harm employees' engagement, well-being, and productivity over time. Toxic positivity is a different animal, and it's important not to confuse the two.

Toxic leadership is about a pattern of harmful behaviour from a specific person in power. Toxic positivity is more often a cultural habit, a communication style that can show up anywhere: in a well-meaning coworker, a peppy company slogan, or an HR email during a round of layoffs.

That said, the two can absolutely overlap. An ineffective manager can weaponize positivity to avoid accountability, responding to legitimate complaints with "let's focus on the positive" instead of actually addressing the problem. In that case, toxic positivity isn't just annoying, it's a tool being used to keep you quiet.

A women frowning sitting in an office surrounded by 4 smiling coworkers
A women frowning sitting in an office surrounded by 4 smiling coworkers

How It Shows Up and Why It Matters

When positivity becomes mandatory, honesty becomes risky. People stop bringing up real problems because they're worried about being seen as negative, difficult, or ungrateful. And once that happens, issues that could have been addressed early just get pushed underground, where they fester into bigger ones: burnout, disengagement, people quietly job hunting while still showing up and smiling in meetings.

A survey from Everything DiSC found that only 53% of people feel comfortable discussing their true feelings with executive leadership, compared to 78% who feel comfortable doing the same with coworkers and managers. That's a massive gap. Think about what it means: the closer you get to power in an organization, the less safe honesty feels. People will tell their work friend the truth about how they're doing over coffee, but they'll smile and say "I'm great, thanks!" the moment a VP walks by. That gap is exactly where toxic positivity lives and grows. If leaders only ever hear the good news, they start to believe the good news is the whole story, and they lose the ability to catch problems while they're still small and fixable.

How to Recover and Push Back on It

If you're in a culture like this, start by giving yourself permission to feel what you're actually feeling. You're not broken, difficult, or ungrateful for having a hard day. You're human.

Find your people. Not everyone deserves the real version of your week, and that's okay. But have a small circle, a trusted coworker, a mentor, a friend outside of work, where you can be honest without having to perform positivity.

Practice what I call realistic optimism instead of toxic positivity. That means holding both truths at once: this is hard right now, and I can still move forward. You don't have to pick one.

And if you're a leader, this one's on you most of all: when someone brings you a problem, resist the urge to immediately reframe it as a silver lining. Listen first. Validate first. Solve second. Your people will tell you the truth far more often if they trust that the truth won't be met with a cheerful dismissal.

Youtube: @dr.laurawhereworkmeetslife

Facebook: @Dr.Laura.whereworkmeetslife

Instagram: @dr.laura.live

Tik Tok: @drlaura.live

X: @drlauralive

Dr. Laura Hambley Lovett is an award winning Organizational Psychologist, Keynote Speaker, Business Leader, International Bestselling Author, and Podcast Host of the highly acclaimed podcast Where Work Meets Life™. She is a sought-after thought leader on workplace psychology, the future of work, and career development with over 25 years of experience. Dr. Laura is passionate about creating cultures that attract top talent and where people stay and thrive.

Dr. Laura has founded several psychology and consulting practices, including Canada Career Counselling in 2009, where registered psychologists across the country have helped thousands of Canadians navigate their career and workplace challenges, while supporting organizations to develop thriving leaders and cultures. She holds a Ph.D. in Industrial/Organizational Psychology from the University of Calgary, where she is currently an Adjunct Professor actively conducting research on toxic leadership across North America.

Her new book about toxic bosses, I Wish I’d Quit Sooner: Practical Strategies for Navigating and Escaping a Toxic Boss, endorsed by Dr. Marshall Goldsmith, was released on January 13, 2026, and became a #1 Amazon bestseller in Workplace Process & Infrastructure, as well as an Amazon International Bestseller. Drawing from her research and decades of experience, the book offers insight, validation, and practical strategies for those navigating, escaping, and recovering from a toxic boss at any stage of one’s career.

She has published two psychological thrillers, Losing Cadence and Finding Sophie, which aim to captivate readers while raising awareness about mental health and domestic violence. These novels are currently being adapted into a television series and inspired her to co-found WITH HER, a movement to end violence against girls and women. In recognition of her impactful work, Dr. Laura received a Canadian Women of Inspiration Award as a Global Influencer in 2018.

Keep Reading

More from the Blog

Stop Listening to the Nasty Voice: Reframe Your Thoughts

October 15, 2026

Stop Listening to the Nasty Voice: Reframe Your Thoughts

Read
Peaks of Perspective: Life & Wellbeing Lessons from my Peruvian Adventure

September 10, 2026

Peaks of Perspective: Life & Wellbeing Lessons from my Peruvian Adventure

Read
Tech Detox and the Weight of the World: Reclaiming Your Right to a Good Day

August 12, 2026

Tech Detox and the Weight of the World: Reclaiming Your Right to a Good Day

Read

Let's get to work

Ready to Transform the Way You Work and Lead?

Partner with Dr. Laura to build a culture where people and performance thrive together.

Get Started

Helping humans and organizations thrive

connect@drlaura.live
Calgary, Alberta · Canada

Explore

  • Home
  • About
  • Coaching
  • Speaking
  • Books

More

  • Media
  • Podcast
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • FAQ

© 2026 Dr. Laura Hambley. All rights reserved. · Sitemap

thrive